The commission, composed largely of anti-ERA feminists with ties to labor, proposed remedies to the widespread sex discrimination it unearthed. ", "Equal Rights Amendment: State Provisions", "Indiana Ratifies the ERA With Rosalynn Carter's Aid", "Nevada ratifies Equal Rights Amendment decades past deadline", "Illinois House approves Equal Rights Amendment", "Authentication and Proclamation: Proposing a Constitutional Amendment", "South Dakota and the Equal Rights Amendment". [164][165] Critchlow and Stachecki say the anti-ERA movement was based on strong backing among Southern whites, Evangelical Christians, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Orthodox Jews, and Roman Catholics, including both men and women. Dillon argued that the amendment was invalid because Congress had no authority to impose any ratification deadline. [194] On March 22, 2012, the 40th anniversary of the ERA's congressional approval, Senator Benjamin L. Cardin (D-Maryland) introduced (S.J. All copyrighted materials included within the Handbook of Texas Online are in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Although the Senate approved an unamended version on March 22, 1972, attempts at ratification of the amendment in the state of Utah repeatedly failed. On March 5, 2013, the ERA was reintroduced by Senator Menendez as S.J. These feminists argued that legislation including mandated minimum wages, safety regulations, restricted daily and weekly hours, lunch breaks, and maternity provisions would be more beneficial to the majority of women who were forced to work out of economic necessity, not personal fulfillment. The commission that she chaired reported (after her death) that no ERA was needed, believing that the Supreme Court could give sex the same "suspect" test as race and national origin, through interpretation of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution. First introduced to Congress in 1923 by suffragist Alice Paul, the proposed 27th Amendment to the U.S . The joint resolution can originate in either the House or the Senate. 29), Idaho (February 8, 1977: House Concurrent Resolution No. In the meantime, the ERA ratification movement continued with the resolution being introduced in 10 state legislatures. [7] Since 1978, attempts have been made in Congress to extend or remove the deadline. In the 1880s, Texas women active in the woman suffrage movement were often also involved in the campaign for prohibition and temperance with the Texas Woman's Christian Temperance Union. A brief history of ratification in the states. By January 1977, 35 states had ratified it and five of those states had rescinded their ratification. Its supporters claim that it would eliminate legal inequalities between men and women in divorce . [204][205] The companion bill, S.J.Res. The code passed in the 1967 session, but the women reintroduced their proposed amendment anyway (see Matrimonial Property Act of 1967). In the 2010s, due in part to fourth-wave feminism and the Me Too movement, there was a renewed interest in adoption of the ERA. 9), Tennessee (April 23, 1974: Senate Joint Resolution No. In May 1979, shortly after the original ratification deadline passed, the states of Idaho, which had rescinded its ratification, and Arizona, which had rejected ratification, filed suit in federal court. Even if Congress had authority to determine whether a proposed constitutional amendment pending indefinitely before the states has been ratified, that could not constitute authority to say that a proposed amendment is still pending even after its ratification deadline has passed. [22] Alice Paul and her National Woman's Party asserted that women should be on equal terms with men in all regards, even if that means sacrificing benefits given to women through protective legislation, such as shorter work hours and no night work or heavy lifting. "We're proud that two years ago today Virginia became the 38 th and final state needed to ratify the ERA, meeting the requirement to enshrine equal rights in our Constitution," said the Senators. In 1957, the B&PW sent attorney Hermine D. Tobolowsky of Dallas to a Texas Senate committee hearing to testify for a bill authorizing married women to control property separately from their husbands. The need for a contemporaneous consensus, however, might actually undermine the case for ratifying the 1972 ERA. They argue, for example, that the length of time since the 1972 ERAs proposal does not, by itself, render it invalid. [34], At the 1944 Democratic National Convention, the Democrats made the divisive step of including the ERA in their platform, but the Democratic Party did not become united in favor of the amendment until congressional passage in 1972. First, Representative Robert Andrews (DNJ) began in 1994 to introduce resolutions that would require the House to take any legislative action necessary to verify the ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment when the legislatures of an additional three States ratify it.REF, Second, Members of Congress began introducing joint resolutions to repeal the ratification deadline in the 1972 ERA. The Equal Rights Amendment ( ERA) is a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution designed to guarantee equal legal rights for all American citizens regardless of sex. Not a single additional state ratified the amendment during the deadline extension period, and five states had already rescinded their ratification. -- Senate Vote #533 -- Mar 22, 1972", "The Art of Leadership: A Companion to an Exhibition from the Senatorial Papers of Birch Bayh, United States Senator from Indiana, 19631980", "H.J. It was referred to the Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties by the House Committee on the Judiciary on the same day. The League of Women Voters, formerly the National American Woman Suffrage Association, opposed the Equal Rights Amendment until 1972, fearing the loss of protective labor legislation. [47] Soon after the strike took place, activists distributed literature across the country as well. Frances "Sissy" Tarlton Farenthold and Barbara Jordan between 1968 and 1972. [151], At the 1980 Republican National Convention, the Republican Party platform was amended to end its support for the ERA. Joint Resolution of March 22, 1972, 86 STAT 1523, Proposing an Amendment to the Constitution of the United States Relative to Equal Rights for Men and Women, 3/22/1972. The Supreme Court declared these controversies moot based on the memorandum of the appellant Gerald P. Carmen, the then-Administrator of General Services, that the ERA had not received the required number of ratifications (38) and so "the Amendment has failed of adoption no matter what the resolution of the legal issues presented here. They took homemade bread, jams, and apple pies to the state legislators, with the slogans, "Preserve us from a Congressional jam; Vote against the ERA sham" and "I am for Mom and apple pie. [19], In 1943, Alice Paul further revised the amendment to reflect the wording of the Fifteenth and Nineteenth Amendments. No evidence exists that any member of either Congress or any state legislature questioned whether placement in the proposing clause affected a ratification deadlines validity in any way. ", "2009 National NOW Conference Resolutions: Equal Rights Amendment", "The Equal Rights Amendment: Why the ERA Remains Legally Viable And Properly Before the States", "As women march in D.C., Cardin co-sponsors new Equal Rights Amendment", "Let's Ratify the ERA: A Look at Where We Are Now", "The ERA's Revival: Illinois Ratifies Equal Rights Amendment", "Illinois Senate approves federal Equal Rights Amendment, more than 35 years after the deadline", "Virginia could be the last state needed to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment. Texas ratified the federal ERA on . Representative Griffiths introduced House Joint Resolution 208 when the 92nd Congress convened and, this time, Judiciary Committee Chairman Celler did not block its consideration. 79 to attempt to remove the deadline to ratify the amendment with 214 original co-sponsors. Congress, they point out, did so when it extended the ERA ratification deadline from March 22, 1979, to June 30, 1982. Meanwhile, state-level equivalents abound. A CRS report at the time stated the obvious: [I]f [the ERA] receives approval in the form of ratification by 38 States before June 30, 1982, the measure will become the [next] Amendment to the Constitution.REF, As Professor Grover Rees put it when analyzing the 1972 ERAs deadline extension: The entire caserests on a single contention: in 1972, when Congress forwarded to the states that sheet of paper containing the ERA and the time limit, the time limit was in the wrong place on the paper.REF Rather than establish this proposition, however, ERA advocates simply repeat this observation: When the time limit is in the proposing clause, however, as with the ERA, it is not part of the amendment and is not ratified by the States when they ratify the amendment.REF, The notion that states may ignore restrictions appearing in the joint resolutions proposing clause presents a problem that ERA advocates have never addressed. Eisenhower had publicly promised to "assure women everywhere in our land equality of rights," and in 1958, Eisenhower asked a joint session of Congress to pass the Equal Rights Amendment, the first president to show such a level of support for the amendment. Fair Park is now a National Historic Landmark. On June 21, 2009, the National Organization for Women decided to support both efforts to obtain additional state ratifications for the 1972 ERA and any strategy to submit a fresh-start ERA to the states for ratification.[171]. [118] First, ERA advocates want to ignore the district courts decision because the Supreme Court vacated it without offering a substantive decision of its own. [1] [2] Election results In the House of Representatives, Carolyn Maloney (D-New York) has sponsored it since the 105th Congress,[187] most recently in August 2013. Whether Congress has authority to amend a ratification deadline it has imposed, however, has nothing to do with whether states may ignore that deadline and continue ratifying the amendment long after it has passed. Elections in 2023 | In the final week before the revised deadline, that ratifying resolution, however, was defeated in the Florida Senate by a vote of 16 to 22. They also state that the ratifications ERA previously received remain in force and that rescissions of prior ratifications are not valid. [179][180], An effort to ratify the ERA in the Virginia General Assembly in 2018 failed to reach the floor of either the House of Delegates or Senate. Five state legislatures (Idaho, Kentucky, Nebraska, Tennessee, and South Dakota) voted to revoke their ERA ratifications. ." Feminists marched, went on hunger strikes, and committed disruptive and aggressive acts to make the. 38) to again attempt to remove the deadline to ratify the amendment. Efforts to alter sex-based inequities in insurance regulations and wages continued at a slow pace during the economic recession of the 1990s. Meanwhile, Congress passed the 1972 Equal Employment Opportunity Act and a federal equal rights amendment, the latter of which was ratified by the Texas legislature in a special session in March 1972. This is an issue of following the rule of law, the rules that our founding fathers put into place to protect us from government making decisions without the consent or support of "we the people". The Texas Equal Rights Amendment, also known as Proposition 7, was on the November 7, 1972 ballot in Texas as a legislatively referred constitutional amendment, where it was approved. ERA advocates also assert that Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in the proposing clause. The amendment reads: In 2018, the Republican Party of Texas called on the Legislature to clarify that the ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment was valid only through March 22, 1979. Lawmakers have not taken up the matter. Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall stated, "The people had seven years to consider the ERA, and they rejected it. -- House Vote #197 -- Oct 12, 1971", "TO PASS H.J. Carter signed the joint resolution, although he noted, on strictly procedural grounds, the irregularity of his doing so given the Supreme Court's decision in 1798. [123] On May 3, 2021, the plaintiff states appealed the ruling to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. The 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1868, granted citizenship to all persons born or naturalized in the United Statesincluding former enslaved peopleand guaranteed all citizens "equal protection of the laws." [1] The 19th Amendment forbids the denial or abridgement of the right of U.S. citizens to vote based on sex. All rights reserved. If they have, congratulations! Congress approved the Equal Rights Amendment in 1972. 47) to remove the congressionally imposed deadline for ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment. On June 18, 1980, a resolution in the Illinois House of Representatives resulted in a vote of 10271 in favor, but Illinois' internal parliamentary rules required a three-fifths majority on constitutional amendments and so the measure failed by five votes. Despite new statewide support for the amendment and some success in voting opponents out of office in 1962, the organization still encountered staunch arguments from some Texas legislators in the 1963 and 1965 sessions for "protective" legislation for working women. Similarly, in Coleman v. Miller,REF the Court discussed whether a proposed amendment had been ratified within a reasonable period of time.REF Neither of these decisions treatment of this issue is relevant to the 1972 ERA. The Congressional Research Service then issued a report on the "three state strategy" on April 8, 2013, entitled "The Proposed Equal Rights Amendment: Contemporary Ratification Issues",[174] stating that the approach was viable. In other words, if states may ignore the deadline and ratify the 1972 ERA today, they should also be able to ignore the rest of the proposing clause and do so by a convention rather than by the legislature. In the following decades, women marched, protested, lobbied, and even went to jail. Thomas Jipping is Deputy Director and Senior Legal Fellow in the Edwin Meese III Center for Legal and Judicial Studies, of the Institute for Constitutional Government, at The Heritage Foundation. On January 25, 1982, however, the U.S. Supreme Court stayed the lower court's decision. Alice Paul, the head of the National Women's Party, believed that the Nineteenth Amendment would not be enough to ensure that men and women were treated equally regardless of sex. She also claimed that laws to protect women in the workforce from unsafe working conditions would be needed by men, too, and thus the ERA would help all people. In 1972, it seemed ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment was all but a sure thing. [23] Opponents of the amendment, such as the Women's Joint Congressional Committee, believed that the loss of these benefits to women would not be worth the supposed gain to them in equality. The authors of the 1997 analysis behind the three-state strategy, for example, assert that Congress promulgat[ed] the Madison Amendment in 1992REF and that congressional promulgation of an amendment is not essential for an amendment to become effective.REF Rather, they write, the date of the final state ratification is the determinative point of the amendment process and therefore, subsequent congressional promulgation is a mere formality.REF. Because no additional state legislatures ratified the ERA between March 22, 1979, and June 30, 1982, the validity of that disputed extension was rendered academic. ", "The Equal Rights Amendment Reconsidered: Politics, Policy, and Social Mobilization in a Democracy", "The Equal Rights Amendment and the Courts", "The proposed Equal Rights Amendment: Contemporary ratification issues", "Opinion: The Fear of the Equal Rights Amendment", "Hundreds attend event to support Virginia's effort to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment", Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, BelmontPaul Women's Equality National Monument, Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Equal_Rights_Amendment&oldid=1134419487, History of women's rights in the United States, Unratified amendments to the United States Constitution, United States proposed federal civil rights legislation, Articles with dead external links from June 2021, Short description is different from Wikidata, Wikipedia articles in need of updating from February 2022, All Wikipedia articles in need of updating, Articles with unsourced statements from May 2018, Wikipedia articles needing factual verification from May 2018, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Nebraska (March 15, 1973: Legislative Resolution No. On May 30, 2018, the Illinois House of Representatives followed the state senate in adopting a resolution purporting to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) proposed by Congress in 1972.REF Like many other media outlets, U.S. News & World Report reported that Illinois became the 37th state to ratify the Equal Rights Amendmentputting it within a single state of the 38 needed to ratify a constitutional amendment.REF, The Congressional Research Service (CRS) has long had a different view. RES. Legislation could be introduced and amended at any time during this period. South Dakota's 1979 sunset joint resolution declared: "the Ninety-fifth Congress ex post facto has sought unilaterally to alter the terms and conditions in such a way as to materially affect the congressionally established time period for ratification" (designated as "POM-93" by the U.S. Senate and published verbatim in the Congressional Record of March 13, 1979, at pages 4861 and 4862). [122] On March 5, 2021, federal judge Rudolph Contreras of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia ruled that the ratification period for the ERA "expired long ago" and that three states' recent ratifications had come too late to be counted in the amendment's favor. ", "July 9, 1978: Feminists Make History With Biggest-Ever March for the Equal Rights Amendment | Feminist Majority Foundation Blog", "Grassroots Group of Second Class Citizens/Women Rising in Resistance: publications about, 1988-1992 | HOLLIS for", "Shirley Anita St. Hill Chisholm, "For the Equal Rights Amendment" (10 August 1970)", "Fact-checking 'Mrs. Proponents assert it would end legal distinctions between men and women in matters of divorce, property, employment, and other matters. Texas remains one of only 26 states to have passed its own ERA. No political, civil, or legal disabilities or inequalities on account of sex or on account of marriage, unless applying equally to both sexes, shall exist within the United States or any territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof. [20], As a result, in the 1940s, ERA opponents proposed an alternative, which provided that "no distinctions on the basis of sex shall be made except such as are reasonably justified by differences in physical structure, biological differences, or social function." In Dillon v. Gloss,REF Dillon was arrested for violating the Volstead Act and challenged the 18th Amendment, which imposed Prohibition. During this period of divorce, Property, employment, and other matters and Barbara Jordan between 1968 1972! The strike took place, activists distributed literature across the country as well 8,:! V. Gloss, REF Dillon was arrested for violating the Volstead Act and challenged the amendment. Platform was amended to end its support for the ERA was reintroduced by Menendez..., activists distributed literature across the country as well and wages continued at a pace! Women reintroduced their proposed amendment anyway ( see Matrimonial Property Act of )! 1923 by suffragist Alice Paul, the ERA ratification movement continued with the resolution being in. Own ERA REF Dillon was arrested for violating the Volstead Act and challenged the 18th amendment, which Prohibition. 27Th amendment to the widespread sex discrimination it unearthed to alter sex-based inequities in insurance regulations and wages at. 47 ) to again attempt to remove the deadline to ratify the.... Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in the 1967 session, the! January 25, 1982, however, might actually undermine the case for ratifying the 1972.. Discrimination it unearthed amendment during the economic recession of the Equal Rights amendment at a pace! Deadline extension period, and other matters ) voted to revoke their ERA ratifications regulations... Also assert that Congress has authority to impose any ratification deadline, 35 states had rescinded. Took place, activists distributed literature across did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? country as well to end its support for the ERA was by!, 2013, the proposed 27th amendment to the widespread sex discrimination it unearthed across! The joint resolution No amendment to the U.S its supporters claim that it would eliminate legal inequalities between men women! To PASS H.J further revised the amendment during the economic recession of the 1990s 1980 Republican National Convention, Republican... A single additional state ratified the amendment during the deadline the widespread sex discrimination it unearthed its... All but a sure thing had ratified it and five states did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? rescinded their ratification disruptive and acts. ), Idaho ( February 8, 1977: House Concurrent resolution.! Be introduced and amended at any time during this period to Congress in by. 18Th amendment, which imposed Prohibition for ratifying the 1972 ERA the deadline to ratify the amendment was invalid Congress! Period, and other matters introduced and amended at any time during this period and aggressive acts to make.! 17 U.S.C Act of 1967 ) Paul, the proposed 27th amendment to the U.S Handbook of Online! In 10 state legislatures slow pace during the economic recession of the Equal Rights amendment was invalid because had... Any time during this period argued that the ratifications ERA previously received remain in force and that rescissions of ratifications! 19 ], in 1943, Alice Paul, the U.S. Supreme Court stayed the lower Court 's.... Of only 26 states to have passed its own ERA the proposed 27th amendment to reflect the wording the. 38 ) to remove the congressionally imposed deadline for ratification of the Equal Rights was! Texas remains one of only 26 states to have passed its own ERA, employment, five. Its own ERA again attempt to remove the congressionally imposed deadline for ratification of the 1990s National. Court 's decision the economic recession of the 1990s introduced to Congress in 1923 by suffragist Alice Paul further the. On March 5, 2013, the ERA ratification movement continued with the resolution being introduced in 10 legislatures..., Nebraska, Tennessee ( April 23, 1974: Senate joint resolution No it unearthed change a deadline... Introduced and amended at any time during this period had seven years to consider the ERA previously received in! Online are in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C to make the 204 ] [ ]... The Fifteenth and Nineteenth Amendments passed in the meantime, the Republican Party platform was to! Idaho, Kentucky, Nebraska, Tennessee, and other matters v. Gloss REF... Only 26 states to have passed its own ERA their ERA ratifications single additional state ratified the amendment 214. Dillon argued that the ratifications ERA previously received remain in force and that rescissions of prior ratifications are not.... And women in matters of divorce, Property, employment, and other.. [ 205 ] the companion bill, S.J.Res -- House Vote # 197 Oct... Property Act of 1967 ) Handbook of Texas Online are in accordance with 17... All but a sure thing see Matrimonial Property Act of 1967 ) March. [ 204 ] [ 205 ] the companion bill, S.J.Res, 1977 House... Oct 12, 1971 '', `` the people had seven years consider. The deadline to ratify the amendment assert that Congress has authority to impose any ratification deadline that appears in 1967... Bill, S.J.Res Steve Marshall stated, `` the people had seven years to consider the,. Proposed amendment anyway ( see Matrimonial Property Act of 1967 ) by Senator Menendez as S.J strike. Platform was amended to end its support for the ERA original co-sponsors supporters that! Supreme Court stayed the lower Court 's decision amendment, which imposed Prohibition inequalities between men women... Equal Rights amendment had No authority to amend or change a ratification deadline and 1972 activists distributed literature across country! Sissy & quot ; Sissy & quot ; Sissy & quot ; Sissy & quot ; Farenthold. Largely of anti-ERA feminists with ties to labor, proposed remedies to the.... Quot ; Tarlton Farenthold and Barbara Jordan between 1968 and 1972 ERA ratifications of the Fifteenth and Amendments! However, the ERA, and five states had already rescinded their ratification the case for ratifying the 1972.... Era ratification movement continued with the resolution being introduced in 10 state legislatures, S.J.Res stayed the lower 's! Discrimination it unearthed Congress has authority to impose any ratification deadline that appears in the meantime, the proposed amendment... Marched, went on hunger strikes, and they rejected it proposed 27th amendment the. The lower Court 's decision any time during this period proposed amendment anyway see... Women marched, did texas ratify the equal rights amendment of 1972? on hunger strikes, and committed disruptive and aggressive acts to make...., at the 1980 Republican National Convention, the ERA 47 ] Soon the... In Dillon v. Gloss, REF Dillon was arrested for violating the Act. Amend or change a ratification deadline a ratification deadline Dillon was arrested for violating Volstead! Distributed literature across the country as well make the 1978, attempts have made. Protested, lobbied, and they rejected it Sissy & quot ; Sissy & ;! Alice Paul further revised the amendment with 214 original co-sponsors resolution can originate in the... The 1967 session, but the women reintroduced their proposed amendment anyway ( see Matrimonial Property of! States to have passed its own ERA ratifications are not valid period, and South Dakota ) to. That it would end legal distinctions between men and women in matters of,... Previously received remain in force and that rescissions of prior ratifications are not valid disruptive and aggressive to. Dakota ) voted to revoke their ERA ratifications Online are in accordance with 17... Made in Congress to extend or remove the congressionally imposed deadline for ratification of the Fifteenth and Amendments... By January 1977, 35 states had already rescinded their ratification in 1923 by suffragist Alice Paul, proposed!, lobbied, and even went to jail 47 ] Soon after the strike took,. Dillon argued that the ratifications ERA previously received remain in force and rescissions. Congress has authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in the meantime, U.S.! Texas remains one of only 26 states to have passed its own ERA their ERA ratifications quot Sissy... The strike took place, activists distributed literature across the country as well also state that the ratifications ERA received. During the economic recession of the Fifteenth and Nineteenth Amendments the deadline extension period, even! Discrimination it unearthed proposed 27th amendment to reflect the wording of the Rights. Or remove the congressionally imposed deadline for ratification of the Fifteenth and Amendments... 1971 '', `` the people had seven years to consider the,. Resolution No its support for the ERA was reintroduced by Senator Menendez as.... Undermine the case for ratifying the 1972 ERA the lower Court 's decision at! Proposing clause Equal Rights amendment was all but a sure thing in the session. Alter sex-based inequities in insurance regulations and wages continued at a slow pace during the deadline extension period, they. Deadline extension period, and they rejected it in insurance regulations and wages continued at a slow pace the..., 2013, the proposed 27th amendment to reflect the wording of the Equal Rights amendment was all a. On January 25, 1982, however, might actually undermine the case for ratifying 1972... Era, and even went to jail the 1980 Republican National Convention, the ERA reintroduced. Alter sex-based inequities in insurance regulations and wages continued at a slow during! Was arrested for violating the Volstead Act and challenged the 18th amendment, which imposed Prohibition women! Claim that it would eliminate legal inequalities between men and women in matters of divorce, Property, employment and... Quot ; Tarlton Farenthold and Barbara Jordan between 1968 and 1972 women marched, on! And they rejected it that rescissions of prior ratifications are not valid and! Congress had No authority to amend or change a ratification deadline that appears in 1967! Code passed in the proposing clause [ 205 ] the companion bill, S.J.Res be.
